← All articles

The Art & Science of Fundraising: 9 Principles from Former Principals

The Art & Science of Fundraising: 9 Principles from Former Principals

Fundraising is a long game, and it often comes with its fair share of challenges. We’ve been there. As leaders who’ve spent years steering our respective organizations—James, formerly at Rocky Mountain Prep and Rich at Lighthouse Community Public Schools—we know how overwhelming it can feel. Yet, we’ve also seen how transformative successful fundraising can be. In reflection, we’ve developed a set of principles to guide the process. Whether you are focused on raising funds through foundations, individual donors, or county, state, and federal competitive grants, these are the lessons we wish we had known earlier, and now, we’re excited to share them with you.

1 — Aim for Elephants

One of the most counterintuitive lessons we’ve learned is that it takes about the same amount of effort to raise $15,000 as it does to raise $500,000. The time and resources you spend cultivating a relationship, drafting a strong application, and navigating the process are often similar, regardless of the donation size. So, prioritize your time where there are larger opportunities. These "elephants" might seem intimidating at first, but the potential impact they can have on your organization is well worth the effort.

2 — It’s Not About You

Fundraising isn’t about what you need—it’s about understanding what motivates your donors as well as understanding how state and federal grant programs are launched and assessed. Successful fundraising is donor-centered. Before approaching a donor, foundation, or government opportunity, invest time in learning about their priorities, values, and Theory of Change. Ask them questions to understand: How does their vision align with our goals? What does their funding process look like? How do they like to stay involved? When you can answer these questions, you’re not just asking for support—you’re inviting them into a meaningful partnership and your work can help them reach their goals.

3 — Build a Map

Clarity is your best friend for you and your team when it comes to fundraising. Do you know your gap and fundraising goal? What is your concrete plan to close the gap? What existing relationships can you build from, and which new funding partners do you need to develop? Give each opportunity a weighted probability and track your progress in a simple spreadsheet or a sophisticated CRM. Whatever will be used consistently is the right tool. For a strong example, take a look at the Fundraising Plan in the Seminar toolbox.

4 — Make It Personal

At its core, fundraising is about relationships. The most successful fundraisers aren’t just skilled at making asks—they’re skilled at building relationships. Take the time to understand your donors as people. What are their goals? What inspires them? Invite them into your world by sharing the unique, sometimes messy challenges your schools face and how you’re tackling them. Don’t be afraid to ask for their input or ideas. When donors feel like they’re part of your team, their commitment deepens.

Here are some tips from other school leaders on how to make your fundraising experience a bit more personal:

“During the holiday season, we send donors holiday cards with notes written by students. They often write back to say how much it meant to them.” — Eldon Lewis, MD of Development, KIPP Texas Public Schools

“Think of donors as long-term friends. My top funders from years ago are still close to me today. Build authentic relationships—visit them, send updates, and involve them in your journey. Treat them like trusted partners.” — Jen Davis Wickens, Founder of Impact Public Schools

5 — TL;DR, BLUF (Bottom Line Up Front)

Be direct. Fundraising isn’t the place for long-winded explanations or ambiguity. Clearly articulate what you’re asking for, why it matters, and how it aligns with the donor’s goals. This approach applies whether you’re working with private donors or submitting government grant applications. For government grants, ensure your application aligns with the legislative policies driving funding decisions. Having a second or third set of eyes review your materials can make all the difference in securing support.

6 — Set Them Up to Win

Often, the program officer or person you are meeting with is not the only or final decision maker. They will often have to present your opportunity to a board or committee. Do they have what they need to make your case compelling? After a gift, highlight how their support will lead to success—whether it’s through well-organized materials, a clear narrative, or a strong track record of wins. People want to feel confident in their investments, and the more you can show them that they’re set up to succeed, the more likely they are to back you. Celebrate their contributions publicly and keep building on the momentum of your shared successes.

7 — Don’t Let a Good Crisis Go to Waste

Nobody wants to hear a constant stream of bad news, but certain crises can present unique opportunities for action. During challenging times, donors often want to feel like they’re making a real difference. Use these moments to tell powerful stories and invite donors to be part of a meaningful solution.

8 — Don’t Take It Personally

If you’re not getting “no’s,” you’re not asking enough. It’s part of the process. Instead of taking these setbacks personally, use them as opportunities to learn and grow. For instance, if your organization gets turned down for a government grant, request feedback to understand how you can improve for the next round as well as awarded applications from other schools, districts, or agencies that cycle. Remember, it’s not about you—it’s about finding the right match as well as improving on future asks.

9 — Articulate a Clear and Bold Vision

A clear, bold vision is your most powerful tool. Tell the bigger story of how your work is creating generational impact and is part of a national movement for educational equity and excellence. Use storytelling to create a strong emotional connection, and help them see how their contribution changes lives. Fundraising isn’t just about asking for money—it’s about giving donors the chance to make a lasting impact.

Fundraising can feel daunting, especially when so much depends on your success. While these principles won’t eliminate every hurdle, they provide a solid foundation to approach your efforts with clarity, purpose, and confidence. Every “no” is an opportunity to refine your strategy, and every win is a step toward your bold vision.

About the Authors

James Cryan is the founder and former CEO of Rocky Mountain Prep, a high-performing network of charter schools in Colorado serving approximately 5,000 scholars. Under James’s leadership, the schools were recognized among the top-performing in the state and honored as one of Denver's Top 100 Workplaces. Driven by the belief that all students deserve an exceptional public education, James has dedicated his career to ensuring every young person can reach their full potential.

After six years of teaching, Rich Harrison served as a principal in Denver, Colorado, where his schools (KIPP: Cole College Prep Academy and Denver School of Science and Technology) showed some of the strongest growth and performance in the state for African American and Latinx students. He then served as the Chief Academic Officer for Uplift Education in the Dallas/Fort Worth region for 8 years and helped grow a system of charter schools serving 20,000 students. Four years ago, Rich moved to the Bay Area to join the Lighthouse Community Public Schools team to lead transformative work in the East Oakland community.

This article is an excerpt from one of Seminar’s expert-led workshops, which provides actionable insights on the topics most relevant to charter school teams. Each workshop is crafted to offer practical templates and strategies, empowering you and your team with knowledge to thrive. Seminar workshops are available to Seminar Core Members.

Learn more about the seminar experience