← All articles

The Bumpy Teacher Dilemma: Mindsets for Tackling Mid-Year Performance Challenges

The Bumpy Teacher Dilemma: Mindsets for Tackling Mid-Year Performance Challenges

The middle of the school year can feel like a pressure cooker. This is the time when cracks start to show—some teachers are thriving, others are struggling, and a few might even have you second-guessing your decision to become a leader in the first place.

But here’s the thing: these challenges aren’t signs of failure. They’re opportunities. Opportunities to recalibrate, refocus, and make real, meaningful changes that benefit your team and your students.

I recently led a Seminar workshop on mid-year performance intervention strategies—what I like to call tackling the “bumpy teacher” problem. It’s not about perfect fixes or overnight transformations. It’s about clarity, action, and creating a culture where everyone has the chance to succeed—or step aside if they need to.

Here are four mindsets I’ve learned over the years and have changed everything for me. My hope is that it gives you some tools—and maybe even a little inspiration—to move forward with confidence.

1. Bad News Doesn’t Get Better with Time. Take Action.

Let me tell you this: a teacher who’s gossiping in September isn’t going to magically stop gossiping in October. The teacher who hasn’t submitted lesson plans on time for months? Without intervention, they’ll still be struggling—and by February, it’ll feel like a five-alarm fire.

Great leaders don’t wait or hope for problems to resolve themselves—because hope is not a plan. If a teacher isn’t standing at the door greeting students as expected, or if they’re falling short on classroom management, they need your attention now. Act early, address the issue directly, and save yourself and your school a world of trouble later on.

2. Your Stars Set Your Organization’s Ceiling.

Your school’s overall quality will only rise as high as your best teachers. Picture a shopping mall: if the anchor stores are discount shops, the vibe is completely different than if the anchor stores are Nordstrom or Saks. The same goes for your school—your "anchor" teachers set the tone for everyone else.

If you want your school to be world-class, you need standout educators to set that bar. Invest in them, elevate them, and let their excellence inspire the rest of your team.

3. Spend More Time with Your Stars.

Here’s the math of employee engagement. For the same unit of effort you put into a staff member:

  • A star will grow 5x
  • A solid performer? Maybe 2x.
  • A struggler? 1/4x.
  • A toxic staff member? -2x. (Yes, negative!)

Yet so often, we pour all our energy into the wrong places—trying to “fix” toxic staff or mediocre performers while ignoring the ones who are already thriving. Flip that script. Spend more time with your stars. Not only will they grow faster, but they’ll also lift the culture and performance of your entire team and school community.

The Harvard Business Review (HBR) article, High Performers Need Feedback, Too, explores the benefits of investing in your high performers, including examples of how you can keep top talent engaged.

4. Twenty Stronger Is Better Than Twenty Strong + Five Weak.

Let’s be honest—losing mediocre performers isn’t the worst thing. In fact, a team of 20 stronger educators will outperform a team of 20 strong ones plus five weak ones every single time.

Too often, we cling to mediocre staff out of fear: What if we can’t replace them? What will happen if we’re understaffed? However, filling a position with another mediocre hire only perpetuates the problem. HBR’s It’s Better to Avoid a Toxic Employee than Hire a Superstar highlights how a bad—or even mediocre—hire can harm your workforce. Instead, focus on redesigning if needed—combine sections, streamline roles, or even adjust your schedule. You’ll find that a leaner, stronger team is far better than trying to carry the weight of mediocrity.

In conclusion:

Here’s the truth: Inaction is a choice—and it’s the wrong one. If someone isn’t meeting expectations, don’t delay. Address it. Put a Performance Improvement Plan (PIP) in place if needed. And if it’s time for them to move on, guide them toward that decision.

At the same time, don’t lose sight of your stars. Elevate them. Recognize their efforts. Shift their responsibilities to maximize their strengths. Pay them if you can. Most importantly, make sure they know how much you value them.

Leadership isn’t easy, but it’s always worth it. And the moment you stop waiting for things to change on their own and start taking intentional action, everything gets a little bit better.

Here’s my challenge to you: Pick one thing—just one. Maybe it’s the tough conversation you’ve been avoiding. Maybe it’s sending a heartfelt message of appreciation to your best teacher. Maybe it’s revisiting how you spend your coaching time.

Whatever it is, act on it. Because leadership isn’t just about managing the present—it’s about creating a future where your team and students thrive.

About the Author

Doug McCurry co-founded Achievement First with a bold goal: to ensure that their schools, serving a student body that was 98% BIPOC and 85% qualifying for free or reduced lunch, would outperform the wealthiest suburban districts. Under his leadership, Achievement First’s schools met this goal, with 8th graders in the network’s New York middle schools outperforming the wealthiest districts in both ELA and Math, and multiple AF high schools earning top state rankings. After 21 years, Doug transitioned from AF and now co-leads Simply Great Schools, which provides school leaders with comprehensive readiness playbooks and training to drive rapid teacher and leader development.

This article is an excerpt from one of Seminar’s expert-led workshops. Seminar workshops provide actionable insights on the topics most relevant to charter school teams. Each workshop is crafted to offer practical templates and strategies, empowering you and your team with knowledge to thrive. Seminar workshops are available to Seminar Core Members.

Learn more about the seminar experience